Tuesday, 7 September 2010

Media Literacy

Introduction to Media Literacy

1)What do people mean by the term Media Literacy?

·There are three main opinions on what Media Literacy means, the first being competence, by this they mean that you are media-literate or media-illiterate. The second opinion is that people see it as a social practice, meaning how we read and make media. The third opinion is that some people see it as a entitlement, that it is there to protect us from potential danger associated with media, especially new media.

2)Who uses the new term Media Literacy?

·The people who use this relatively new term but is widely used by educators, poilcymakers, regulators and media producers.

3)There are many different definitions of media literacy given by media experts, what are the definitions given by the OCR senior examiners?

·The ability to create, use, analyse and understand media products, within the context of their audiences and institutions. (Donna Cooper-Cliftlands, OCR Senior Examiner)

·A broader version of conventional literacy, which includes all visual, aural and digital forms, seeking to enable people to become more thoughtful producers and interpreters of media. (Pete Fraser, OCR Senior Examiner)

·Media Literacy can be defined as the ability to read a media text, in understanding the process of communication through the construction of an artefact and its sets of representations. The ability to read a media text, in its visual or audio form, is itself paramount to understanding the meaning that a text may convey, which is dependent upon the individual, psychological and sociocultural context of the reader. (Jason Mazzochi, OCR Senior Examiner)

·Media literacy is the ability to understand how any media text constructs its meaning as much through its form as its content. (James Baker, OCR Senior Examiner)

·Media literacy is being able to engage not just with the immediate content of a media text, but also to be able to apply knowledge and understanding of the institutional factors that have an impact on shaping the text itself and on the messages and values embedded within the text. Media literacy also involves knowledge and understanding of how different audiences in different times and places may interpret the text in different ways. Crucially, the media-literate reader of the text is able to see that his/her own reading of the text may well be at odds with that applied by some or all of the target audience. (Wayne O’Brien. OCR Senior Examiner)

4)What one of the definitions given by the OCR senior examiners, would you agree most with, and why?

·Personally I agree with the definition given by Wayne O’Brien, as he goes into great detail. He talks about be able to look beyond the product itself and be able to apply knowledge to how it was made and what effected the shaping of the text. He also mentions how people with different backgrounds have different interpretations of the same thing.

5)What was the quote in “The Media Teacher’s Book” that was referred to by its author at the “establishing shot”?

·“I see a progressive story: mass culture growing more sophisticated, demanding more cognitive engagement with each passing year. Think of it as a kind of positive brainwashing: the popular media steadily, but almost imperceptibly, making our minds sharper, as we soak in entertainment usually dismissed as so much lowbrow fluff.” (Steven Johnson, 2005)

6)Why is it that many people “demonise” young people?

·The main reason for why people demonise young people is due to their text language, digital television, MySpace and video games. Besides these reasons people think the reason why people demonise young people is due to the jealousy of youth that is gained through the ageing process. Also people believe that the music, television, film and culture were generally better in their teenage years.

7)What is it that Nick Barham says about the “disconnect” between games players and those who make assumptions about how games are influencing them.

·“Modern entertainment fans have little respect or time for people who don’t understand something, making comments about the effect that it has on the people who do understand it.” (Nick Barham, 2004)

8)What is it that you think Nick Barham means by his quote?

·My personal interpretation of the quote is that he thinks that young people do not care what others may think of their entertainment as they don’t try to understand it but just assume that it is bad. The young people do not bother or have any time for someone who just assumes the worse, without experiencing it for themselves.

9)What are the serious concerns about modern culture?

·The main concern is the way modern culture is “saturated” by the media and entertainment. There are associated anxieties about losing control of what people are doing, knowing where they are virtually and how they are communicating. Also people are concerned that they are missing out on a more enriching culture, experiencing novels, plays, news and arts. Whereas Johnson believes the opposite, he believes that the multi-layered nature of television, the nature of blogging and intense motivational energy shown by players is ultimately making people more intelligent.

10)What is the whole idea of Media Studies?

·The whole idea of the subject is to do with you creating media and developing a theoretical understanding of media in society – including your own media.

11)What is meant by the term “relativist” when describing Media Studies?

·This basically means that there are no judgements being made about which media texts are of more values than others, unlike other subjects like English where books are labelled for example “Classic Literature” and “Fiction”.

12)What are the essentials to know when moving from AS to A2?

·The essential thing is to understand the difference between just using the media and making the media and also to be media-literate enough to qualify with an A-Level in the subject.

13)What is the difference between the relationship of an A2 media student involved with media and the relationship between someone not doing media studies involved with media?

·People who are involved with media but do not studying it as a subject will most likely develop interesting things to say on various forms of media for example YouTube, T.V programmes and DJ. But an A2 media student will be able to create media material that observes a set of conventions and have provide a research based mode of address for your audience, also being able to theorise your own media creativity. Using such academic ideas as postmodernism, democracy, representation and discourse.

14)What is the difference made by studying media?

·More developed theoretical understanding of how literacy is being reframed by digital culture, so that you not only demonstrate your own high levels of media literacy. But also offer an intellectual, academic and informed of media literacy when reflecting on your own creative outcomes and processes and how the contemporary media and culture are “read” in new ways.

15)What is the term literacy traditionally been associated with?

·The term literacy is commonly associated with reading and writing and discussed in relation to deficit – people were seen to be literate or not. Those who were illiterate were the target groups for educational programmes, equipping them with literacy. But there was little discussion on the levels of literacy and the different types of literacy.

16)What is Web 2.0?

·Web 2.0 is the second phase of the internet, defined as a new stage by the rapid increase of content and ideas being shared online by ordinary people. Although the term “Web 2.0” is being criticised through the argument that only small percentages of ordinary people upload their own content and that the term is more “Web 1.5” then “Web 2.0”.

17)What is the impact of Web 2.0?

·It has had a huge impact as it has made a big difference to how the media are distributed and exchanged.

18)What is the relation between media literacy and Web 2.0?

·Web 2.0 is considered by experts as a profound historical shift in how people communicate, how they read and write and what these things now mean. It is Web 2.0 that leads to the concept of “new literacies”.

New Literacies

1)What is the result in the difference between “old-school literacy” and “Web 2.0”?

·A range in theories and strategies based on literacy as a social and political practice.

2)What is Freire’s (1972) theory on literacy?

·He described that how people are excluded from literacy and without it disempowered in relation to social structure, basically if someone cannot read or write, there are many things they cannot conceptualise, understand and participate in.

3)What is it that Freire thinks the implications of being excluded from literacy are?

·Without literacy it makes it very hard for a person to develop a critical view of the world, so that someone who lacks literacy can be put in place, oppressed and even controlled. So literacy is placed in the centre stage in the desire to promote social justice, ultimately making the world a better place.

4)What did Lankshear and Knobel (2006) say about Freire’s theory?

·“Within Freire’s approach to literacy, the process of learning to read and write words was an integral part of learning to understand how the world operates socially and culturally in ways that promote unequal opportunities and outcomes for different groups of people. Ultimately this was a starting point for participants to take action on the world in an attempt to change it in ways that would create social processes and relations that were more just. Groups would undertake cultural action for change in the world in the light of their understanding of their circumstances.”

5)What is Gordon Brown’s (during the time of writing) think about immigrants living or claiming benefits within the UK?

·That they should learn to read and write because if they don’t make the effort to learn literacy then they are excluding themselves from the country they have chosen to move to. Without their effort to learn the spoken language, then they are more likely to see themselves as outsiders. Whereas people who do the language are cohesive with the country and are less likely to see the host nation as an enemy.

6)What are the similarities between Gordon Brown’s and Freire’s view on literacy?

·Both Gordon Brown and Freire share the belief that literacy is linked to social change.

7)What are the differences between Gordon Brown’s and Freire’s views on literacy?

·Although they believe literacy is linked to social change, Freire sees literacy a way out of social control, literacy being empowering in a critical sense. Whereas Gordon Brown sees the obligation of literacy as a form of social control or at least as an aspect of social cohesion.

8)What do OFCOM believe is the benefit to media literacy?

·They believe that it will create more responsible media consumers as an alternative to censorship. That media-literate citizen will self-regulate their use of media so that the chances of people being negatively affected by violent video games or urban rap music will reduce if the audience have the critical skills to decode what they are hearing/seeing/reading/playing.

9)What does the benefit of media literacy as said by Ofcom achieve?

·What this achieves is that there is more empowerment, social justice and social control.

10)What is it that James Gee had to say about literacy?

·He states that people need to operate within several literacies to be successful in society and that a higher level of literacy is achieved by those who understand how to use different literacies at different times – the development of a “meta-understanding” of literacies as discourses. He calls this skill “powerful literacy”.

11)Through what examples does James Gee use to demonstrate “powerful literacy”?

·He uses a football commentary as a example. He mentions how the commentator uses terms such as “keeping it tight”, “losing the shape” and “stopping them playing” and the audience would either immediately understand and responds to the terms or not understand. So at this stage you are either included or excluded by the discourse of football. But if you can switch from that discourse to another one, for example a formal meeting at work – without thinking about it, then you are working with more than one literacy. He also gives the example of how a plumber is not only able to use a shower but also understands the way the water pressure works. Also how some people know what to do when a computer crashes and how some others don’t.

12)Language and literacy are both tools for us to use and systems for us to understand, what is the implication of this?

·The implications of these are that the word literacy has been used virtually in recent years to describe every area of human activity. This is often done without much attention to these more complex aspects, as described by Gee. So we get emotional literacy, computer literacy, physical literacy and functional literacy. It is important when discussing any of these to keep in mind the range of ways of being literate that we have explored here, and not to go back to thinking of these literacies as things you have, need or can “get” quickly.

13)What is literacy in a nutshell?

·In a nutshell, literacy is social and it is practised in contexts – it cannot be learned or measured in isolation from social life and interation.

14)Summarise the information that has been gathered in the “New Literacies” section of questions.

·So far we have thought about literacy as a commodity – you have it or you do not have it – as an aspect of integration into society, as a critical tool that leads to freedom, and has an element of social control. It is a fundamental point that literacy is social and that “powerful literacy” is the ability to step outside of discourses and be critical about them.


Digital Literacy

1)What is the point of digital literacy?

·The political nature for media literacy in terms of inclusion and exclusion is that it is a tool for reducing the “digital divide”, thus having a social justice agenda.

2)What are the cultural developments and how is this related to literacy?

·YouTube, social networking sites, on-demand media, video games, virtual worlds and MP3 are all cultural developments arising from technological change, and it is argued, the cultural part of this relates to the new ways in which we communicate and participate now, that were not possible before Web 2.0.

Memes and Remix

1)What is meant by the term “meme”?

·Meme is a popular term for describing the rapid uptake and spread of a particular idea presented as a written text, image, language “move” or some other unit of cultural “stuff”.

2)Give an example for when the term “meme” would be applied?

·A remix video called “Read my lips Bush/Blair love song” was posted on YouTube, it was viewed by a huge audience and then, crucially, disseminated across a range of more traditional media.

3)How does a “meme” work?

·A “meme” will communicate a particular idea, signified in an interesting and “novel” way; it will assume a shared response from a cultural group and thus relate to a particular discourse about the world; and it will be exchanged widely through forms of social action and engagement – in simple terms, when people “pass on” the meme, they will be reinforcing their own sense of the world.

4)Explain how the term “meme” was related to the seminal book “The Selfish Gene”. (2006)

·Dawkins used the term “meme” in relation to Darwinian principles of evolution, arguing that it is an aspect of human nature, related to survival instincts, that we will pass on ideas in various cultural contexts, just as a gene is circulated in biological terms. The term for online word-of-mouth promotion, intended or otherwise is “viral marketing” – ideas spread through culture, like a virus spreads through a population.

5)What is it that Dixon (2008) had to say about the “internet meme” and how it relates to the past?

·“In common usage, the neologism ‘internet meme’ refers to the propagation of a (often humorous) digital file from one person to others, much in the same way jokes and cartoons were photocopied in offices in the 70’s and 80’s. What is crucially evolve through informal networks, even often engendering imitations or parodies of itself.” He is saying how even before the term “internet meme” was created there was a form of meme. He states that the internet meme is an evolved version of what existed before he specially says “through informal networks”. By this he means that the internet is more direct and less personal whereas the pre-evolved version of the internet meme was the photocopying in offices.

Ofcom and Media Literacy

1)What is it that the regulatory body Ofcom attempted in May 2008?

·Ofcom attempted to hold a Media Literacy Research Forum in London and a group of media experts developed a framework for media literacy. But ended up with loads of different versions.

2)Give a summary of the main issues presented from the Media Literacy Research Forum?

·Need to educate and develop people so they can access, evaluate and create media.
·Changing media behaviour is due to domestic situations as well as new technology.
·Trust of media content is a problem and people lack literacy in this regard.
·A self-help culture is emerging, manual guides rarely accessed.
·Outsourcing responsibility of regulation.
·DIY media production and media literacy.
·Assumption of “digital natives”.
·Assumption that uploading content is worthwhile.
·Literacy embedded in social experiences; think of media literacy as being to do with communication and distribution.

3)Discuss the difficulties of media literacy?

·Robin Blake of Ofcom says that “media literacy is just the literacy of our times”, that cannot mean that we take it for granted or assume it develops naturally just because we are exposed to so much media. That would be like surrounding a child with books and expecting her to learn to read on her own. In fact, as Sonia Livingstone pointed out, the modern media world can be illegible, hard to understand and very hard to trust compared to analogue culture. There is a need to work harder as a society to develop literacy capabilities.

Media Literacy for A2

1)What is it that David Gauntlett said about media studies 2.0 in relation to Web 2.0?

·“The view of the internet and new digital media as an ‘optional extra’ is replaced with recognition that they have fundamentally changed the ways in which we engage with all media.”

2)What questions arise from the study of media?

·Do people ‘watch television’ in the traditional sense anymore?
·Are there any distinct ‘media institutions’ in the era of convergence?
·If you can share music on Facebook with your ‘friends’, and they can purchase it at the click of a mouse and then access the video almost immediately on YouTube, how does this change the music industry?
·Is there any such a thing as ‘the audience’ in this day and age?

3)What is it that Guantlett is suggesting? And how does this affect media studies?

·People do not just get represented by the media anymore. Instead, they use web 2.0 platforms to make their own media, share it with the world and thus represent themselves. So media studies now need to engage with the ways in which people make sense of their identities and then creatively. Through the media, express this. This means that media students need to move away from the ‘media 1.0’way of doing things by ‘questioning the traditional approach to people who “produce” media and people who “use” media’, and by encouraging creative responses.

4)Give two professional opinions on what media 2.0 is about?

·One opinion is from Dan Gillmor’s book “We, the Media” (2004) Looking specifically at ‘citizen journalism’ in the form of blogs, Gillmor offers a similar assertion to Gauntlett, arguing that web 2.0 enables ordinary people to participate in politics and news, by producing their own accounts of real events and commenting immediately (and loudly) on ‘official’ journalism.
·Another media academic, John Hartley (2007) describes the shift from a demand-led market of creative industries to a social network market. Describing the long tail of media distribution, he suggests that the liberating potential of web 2.0 might be equal not only to the emergence of ‘mass literacy’, but beyond that, to the introduction of mass public schooling.

Britney 2.0

1)What was the claim made by Alastair Campbell (previously Tony Blair’s press officer and spin doctor) in 2008?

·Britney has ceased to be considered a human being by the public and is now understood primarily as a news commodity.

2)State what is meant by Britney 1.0 and Britney 2.0?

·Britney 1.0 and Britney 2.0 state the ways in which people talk about Britney Spears in the media. The 1.0 list and the 2.0 list, both are merged together to create on 2.0 list of Britney. This addition is not an optional extra however, a person cannot make sense of what Alastair said about the pop singer without debating the extent of which her commodification is amplified and accelerated by online media as her as a ‘sign’.

Fan Culture

1)Explain what fan culture in relation to web 2.0 along with examples?

·Hills (2002) analyses fandom as a form of cultural expression although many of his examples had no relation to web 2.0 for example Trekkies and Elvis impersonators – but it was clear that broadband internet can accelerate fan interpretations and reimagining’s of media products. In today’s media there is a enormous range of ‘mash up’ and ‘sweded’ video material on YouTube. From Harry Porter fans sharing fan literature online, to the many commentary edits of ‘The Sopranos’ finale that you can find online, media producers now have to accept that fans can and will upload their own versions of material within hours of the official broadcast.

2)What most a student do successfully in order to become a media 2.0 student?

·The main thing is we need to approach media products in a academic (when looking at existing media) and creative (when making your own) way that combines tried and tested concepts, such as representation, with an understanding of how people make sense of media in the online age.